|
本帖最后由 八翼天使 于 2015-10-11 16:57:49 编辑
无双美女神将西施（下）
无双美女神将西施（上） 上部分我们已经测试了美女西施的攻击情况，策略和战法比大概1.66:1，相当于62:38。策略的比重偏大。这是完全破防的数据，实际上没有破防情况下，总体差异没有这么明显。现在看看西施的防御情况。一直有人说西施隐藏普攻、战法防御加强。是不是这样，笔者做了很多组测试来验证这个猜想是否正确。
ignore_js_opimg id="aimg_1258521"src="https://res-bbs.aoshitang.com/data/attachment/forum/201510/11/1258521e3a0f19eda510eeb043bef97b58f00e5.jpg"style="max-width: 750px;"zoomfile="https://res-bbs.aoshitang.com/data/attachment/forum/201510/11/1258521e3a0f19eda510eeb043bef97b58f00e5.jpg"file="https://res-bbs.aoshitang.com/data/attachment/forum/201510/11/1258521e3a0f19eda510eeb043bef97b58f00e5.jpg"class="zoom"onclick="zoom(this, this.src)"onmouseover="showMenu({'ctrlid':this.id,'pos':'12'})"alt=""//ignore_js_opignore_js_opimg id="aimg_1258523"src="https://res-bbs.aoshitang.com/data/attachment/forum/201510/11/12585238f4fba59962555566224cc4af66ea8be.jpg"style="max-width: 750px;"zoomfile="https://res-bbs.aoshitang.com/data/attachment/forum/201510/11/12585238f4fba59962555566224cc4af66ea8be.jpg"file="https://res-bbs.aoshitang.com/data/attachment/forum/201510/11/12585238f4fba59962555566224cc4af66ea8be.jpg"class="zoom"onclick="zoom(this, this.src)"onmouseover="showMenu({'ctrlid':this.id,'pos':'12'})"alt=""//ignore_js_op
防御测试选用300级地图的百家守卫1，闪避阵型，测试对象咆天虎卫，因为其普攻战法比例为47:53，大体相当，便于验证减伤比例。同时保证无宝石时完全破防，伤害最大，带宝石时伤害最小。测试采用八卦阵，装备为策攻战法攻兵力套装，无淬炼，蓝色无双春秋史头盔。普通58左右红宝。雷霆战车16级。
ignore_js_opimg id="aimg_1258533"src="https://res-bbs.aoshitang.com/data/attachment/forum/201510/11/125853392c637cc5ba53ef2ef10f9ee1cf92313.jpg"style="max-width: 750px;"zoomfile="https://res-bbs.aoshitang.com/data/attachment/forum/201510/11/125853392c637cc5ba53ef2ef10f9ee1cf92313.jpg"file="https://res-bbs.aoshitang.com/data/attachment/forum/201510/11/125853392c637cc5ba53ef2ef10f9ee1cf92313.jpg"class="zoom"onclick="zoom(this, this.src)"onmouseover="showMenu({'ctrlid':this.id,'pos':'12'})"alt=""//ignore_js_op
测试分两大部分，先测试西施、神诸葛亮、郭嘉等类似武将的防御情况，再测试西施自身各种情况下的减伤。
【同类策士抗战法对比】 选择诸葛亮、郭嘉作为类比对象，一来他们都是策攻为主，战法攻击为辅。其次诸葛亮、郭嘉对各类攻击都没有防御加强。 先看看无宝石情况下他们三者被咆天虎卫攻击的伤害值。 ignore_js_opimg id="aimg_1258525"src="https://res-bbs.aoshitang.com/data/attachment/forum/201510/11/125852560d1033cff5ea940378984ea44a63dcc.jpg"style="max-width: 750px;"zoomfile="https://res-bbs.aoshitang.com/data/attachment/forum/201510/11/125852560d1033cff5ea940378984ea44a63dcc.jpg"file="https://res-bbs.aoshitang.com/data/attachment/forum/201510/11/125852560d1033cff5ea940378984ea44a63dcc.jpg"class="zoom"onclick="zoom(this, this.src)"onmouseover="showMenu({'ctrlid':this.id,'pos':'12'})"alt=""//ignore_js_opignore_js_opimg id="aimg_1258527"src="https://res-bbs.aoshitang.com/data/attachment/forum/201510/11/1258527836b44137e38db95a1a0425c50300971.jpg"style="max-width: 750px;"zoomfile="https://res-bbs.aoshitang.com/data/attachment/forum/201510/11/1258527836b44137e38db95a1a0425c50300971.jpg"file="https://res-bbs.aoshitang.com/data/attachment/forum/201510/11/1258527836b44137e38db95a1a0425c50300971.jpg"class="zoom"onclick="zoom(this, this.src)"onmouseover="showMenu({'ctrlid':this.id,'pos':'12'})"alt=""//ignore_js_op西施损血 ignore_js_opimg id="aimg_1258529"src="https://res-bbs.aoshitang.com/data/attachment/forum/201510/11/1258529031d9c637b174d84ec44965b0bec8679.jpg"style="max-width: 750px;"zoomfile="https://res-bbs.aoshitang.com/data/attachment/forum/201510/11/1258529031d9c637b174d84ec44965b0bec8679.jpg"file="https://res-bbs.aoshitang.com/data/attachment/forum/201510/11/1258529031d9c637b174d84ec44965b0bec8679.jpg"class="zoom"onclick="zoom(this, this.src)"onmouseover="showMenu({'ctrlid':this.id,'pos':'12'})"alt=""//ignore_js_opignore_js_opimg id="aimg_1258531"src="https://res-bbs.aoshitang.com/data/attachment/forum/201510/11/12585314ef5e841daecc181f36e71265103c508.jpg"style="max-width: 750px;"zoomfile="https://res-bbs.aoshitang.com/data/attachment/forum/201510/11/12585314ef5e841daecc181f36e71265103c508.jpg"file="https://res-bbs.aoshitang.com/data/attachment/forum/201510/11/12585314ef5e841daecc181f36e71265103c508.jpg"class="zoom"onclick="zoom(this, this.src)"onmouseover="showMenu({'ctrlid':this.id,'pos':'12'})"alt=""//ignore_js_op诸葛亮损血 ignore_js_opimg id="aimg_1258535"src="https://res-bbs.aoshitang.com/data/attachment/forum/201510/11/125853584ca578a6113ebd1adc8eb70fe3316c0.jpg"style="max-width: 750px;"zoomfile="https://res-bbs.aoshitang.com/data/attachment/forum/201510/11/125853584ca578a6113ebd1adc8eb70fe3316c0.jpg"file="https://res-bbs.aoshitang.com/data/attachment/forum/201510/11/125853584ca578a6113ebd1adc8eb70fe3316c0.jpg"class="zoom"onclick="zoom(this, this.src)"onmouseover="showMenu({'ctrlid':this.id,'pos':'12'})"alt=""//ignore_js_opignore_js_opimg id="aimg_1258537"src="https://res-bbs.aoshitang.com/data/attachment/forum/201510/11/125853767d105cdec5234d1b5fb9792efed6a0c.jpg"style="max-width: 750px;"zoomfile="https://res-bbs.aoshitang.com/data/attachment/forum/201510/11/125853767d105cdec5234d1b5fb9792efed6a0c.jpg"file="https://res-bbs.aoshitang.com/data/attachment/forum/201510/11/125853767d105cdec5234d1b5fb9792efed6a0c.jpg"class="zoom"onclick="zoom(this, this.src)"onmouseover="showMenu({'ctrlid':this.id,'pos':'12'})"alt=""//ignore_js_op郭嘉损血
具体统计数据见下表。从中可以看出，郭嘉、诸葛亮面对完全破防的战法将，损血差不多，122000左右。西施情况好很多，大概79500左右。直观的看，西施对咆天虎卫的减伤比例大概在35%左右。 下面再看看上统勇宝石，诸葛亮和西施的损血情况。西施的损血平均为29000，诸葛亮的损血平均为44900，西施的减伤比例同样为35%左右。 ignore_js_opimg id="aimg_1258539"src="https://res-bbs.aoshitang.com/data/attachment/forum/201510/11/1258539535cb8150a260a9b0427e46e2b8dd36a.jpg"style="max-width: 750px;"zoomfile="https://res-bbs.aoshitang.com/data/attachment/forum/201510/11/1258539535cb8150a260a9b0427e46e2b8dd36a.jpg"file="https://res-bbs.aoshitang.com/data/attachment/forum/201510/11/1258539535cb8150a260a9b0427e46e2b8dd36a.jpg"class="zoom"onclick="zoom(this, this.src)"onmouseover="showMenu({'ctrlid':this.id,'pos':'12'})"alt=""//ignore_js_op
ignore_js_opimg id="aimg_1258541"src="https://res-bbs.aoshitang.com/data/attachment/forum/201510/11/125854116ed4aa76f0e8d1004d92c6e6c49b2b2.jpg"style="max-width: 750px;"zoomfile="https://res-bbs.aoshitang.com/data/attachment/forum/201510/11/125854116ed4aa76f0e8d1004d92c6e6c49b2b2.jpg"file="https://res-bbs.aoshitang.com/data/attachment/forum/201510/11/125854116ed4aa76f0e8d1004d92c6e6c49b2b2.jpg"class="zoom"onclick="zoom(this, this.src)"onmouseover="showMenu({'ctrlid':this.id,'pos':'12'})"alt=""//ignore_js_op 上述测试说明，西施对张飞、黄忠类战法将的总体减伤比例为35%左右。
【西施普防战法防测试】 前面测试说明，西施对战法将防御有所加强，对普攻战法攻相当的减伤比例为35%左右。那么是单纯的普防加强、战法防御加强，还是二者都有？ 防御测试同样分四种情况：无宝石，单统宝石，单勇宝石，统勇宝石。各项数据分别如下： ignore_js_opimg id="aimg_1258543"src="https://res-bbs.aoshitang.com/data/attachment/forum/201510/11/1258543ebd3848102851b5892dd23f46c0215b4.jpg"style="max-width: 750px;"zoomfile="https://res-bbs.aoshitang.com/data/attachment/forum/201510/11/1258543ebd3848102851b5892dd23f46c0215b4.jpg"file="https://res-bbs.aoshitang.com/data/attachment/forum/201510/11/1258543ebd3848102851b5892dd23f46c0215b4.jpg"class="zoom"onclick="zoom(this, this.src)"onmouseover="showMenu({'ctrlid':this.id,'pos':'12'})"alt=""//ignore_js_op
从上表可以看出，无宝石平均损血为79511， 单统宝石平均损血为55755，单勇宝石平均损血为52245，统勇宝石平均损血29023。 平均勇损血55755-29023=26732； 平均统损血52245-29023=23222； 总损血26732+23222+29023=78977；和79511相当。说明测试结果防御完全破防。 同时勇损血：统损血=26732:23222=53:47，这和咆天虎卫的勇统比一致。
上述测试还是没有办法确认减伤的35%中哪些是统，哪些是勇？笔者再拿300级地图中百家精锐1中机关兽作为测试对象，和郭嘉对比，发现统减伤为20%左右。说明西施对机械物理攻击是免伤的，但机械暴击系数不同，减伤比例不能作为依据。笔者又拿300级地图百家守卫3中的追命铁骑作为测试对象。和郭嘉对比，西施减伤比例为34%左右（无宝石情况）。由于追命铁骑的普攻和战法攻击比例为54:46，和咆天虎卫的47:53正好相反。结合二者的测试，可以得出结论：西施对战法将的普攻、战法攻击免伤比例约为35%左右。 PS：笔者还专门测试过西施、郭嘉无宝石情况下假太史慈的伤害，免伤比例为28%，估计是300士气的影响。 ignore_js_opimg id="aimg_1258545"src="https://res-bbs.aoshitang.com/data/attachment/forum/201510/11/12585450f7268904e2dde969c2b0278b440c705.jpg"style="max-width: 750px;"zoomfile="https://res-bbs.aoshitang.com/data/attachment/forum/201510/11/12585450f7268904e2dde969c2b0278b440c705.jpg"file="https://res-bbs.aoshitang.com/data/attachment/forum/201510/11/12585450f7268904e2dde969c2b0278b440c705.jpg"class="zoom"onclick="zoom(this, this.src)"onmouseover="showMenu({'ctrlid':this.id,'pos':'12'})"alt=""//ignore_js_opignore_js_opimg id="aimg_1258547"src="https://res-bbs.aoshitang.com/data/attachment/forum/201510/11/125854715e3588bb737c5b05c4f88fa67ec8615.jpg"style="max-width: 750px;"zoomfile="https://res-bbs.aoshitang.com/data/attachment/forum/201510/11/125854715e3588bb737c5b05c4f88fa67ec8615.jpg"file="https://res-bbs.aoshitang.com/data/attachment/forum/201510/11/125854715e3588bb737c5b05c4f88fa67ec8615.jpg"class="zoom"onclick="zoom(this, this.src)"onmouseover="showMenu({'ctrlid':this.id,'pos':'12'})"alt=""//ignore_js_op
综上所述，西施对战法将的总体免伤比例为35%左右，对普攻、战法攻击免伤比例基本一致，均为35%左右。那么，要发挥西施的作用，12个宝石是最佳选择。推图肯定没有12个宝石给西施，或者说其性价比远不如鬼谷子（普攻、战法免伤75%）、荆轲。PK情况下，用西施更加不利，原因如下： 1. 没有12个宝石给她，如果只给8个宝石，效果远不如鬼谷子，况且普通玩家最多给她4个宝石； 2. 西施的统属性只有101，勇属性115，大多数玩家装备淬炼统，面对始皇、张飞，即使给西施统宝石，被破防可能性很大，意义不大； 3. 普通玩家的宝石、头盔最多3套，没有多的资源给辅助将，没有宝石、头盔等支持下，西施妹子很脆弱； 结论就是西施很不错，但需要优质资源才能发挥其优点，普通玩家养不起，用不起，只有放在后花园养眼。
|
